Price: 80 cents
Location: Big Lots
It is common knowledge that Elvis Presley's favorite food was a peanut butter and banana sandwich. In some versions of the legend, the sandwich was (be still my heart) fried. I have always felt a special kinship with the King ever since hearing that he had a taste for unconventional food. I imagine that before he was a big deal people gave him weird looks when he tucked into a PB&B, the same way no one understands my passionate love of fried pickles. So you can understand my excitement at scoring these peanut butter & banana creme Reese's cups at Big Lots. And man, they were worth it.
First of all, they were huge peanut butter cups. I guess there is a special kind of Reese's PB Cup now, called a Big Cup, and it's about the size of a hockey puck (okay, not quite that, but close!). That's what these things were. As you can see in the above cross-section, the standard peanut butter sits atop a layer of banana creme. I'm not a big fan of bananas, and even less so of banana-flavored things, but this was actually really good. I would definitely be open to trying other flavor combinations of the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, especially if they had historical context like these did.
As a side note, Big Lots is the best place ever to find things like this. For the uninitiated, Big Lots is a store where regular stores send their extra stuff. A lot of discontinued things end up there, as well as some things (like the Elvis PB Cups) that I had never even seen in regular stores. It's about on par with the dollar store as far as prices, maybe a little more. Other times at Big Lots I've found things like Bruschetta-flavored Pringles and Jeff Foxworthy Brand Ham Jerky. You find something new every time.